Does Islam Need a Luther or a Pope? →
It has become the conventional wisdom … since 9/11 that the trouble with Islam is that, unlike Christianity, it never had a Protestant Reformation. The idea seems to be this: Christianity was (so it is held) rigid and authoritarian before Luther and company came along and paved the way for liberal democracy, science, and all things modern and good; Islam’s problem is that it remains stuck in its “Medieval phase,” still awaiting Reformers of its own.
This analysis dovetails nicely with the conceptions most people have these days of the Reformation, of traditional Catholicism, and of freedom and rationality and their relationship to authority and tradition. It is, for that reason, completely worthless. For such conceptions rest largely on clichés whose content owes less to actual historical fact than to the needs of Reformation and Enlightenment era anti-Catholic polemic.
— Does Islam Need a Luther or a Pope?. Feser, Edward. TCS Daily. 4 Dec. 2003.
